Home     Site Map     Village Forum     Search     Help     About us

Home War Index

Abel Ashburner William James Ashburner William Ball John Banks Fred Bell Lancelot Thomas Bell Claude L Blair MC William Calvert John William Cartmell William Connors Henry Robert & John Harrington Oswald Rees Keene Stanley Kenworthy William Ewart Mawson Clement Mossop James McKee William Scott McNeal Henry (Harry) Nankivell J. Nicholson Ferdinand William Pryor Herbert Hopkin Rees Tom Dalzell Rothery James Stainton Thomas Robley Steele Alfred Taylor Edward Telfer James Thompson Joseph Varah George William Walker

St Bees Dead of the First World War

Arms of King George V

Roll of Honour

James Stainton


lst Bn Border Regiment

Killed in Action, the Somme 1916, aged 31

THIS ENTRY IS CONJECTURAL

I have had some difficulty over the identity of the 'J. Stainton' on our memorials. A large part of the problem is that although the records show four Stainton families in our area at the relevant time, none had a member with the initial J.

Of the forty-one Staintons killed in the First World war, I think we can narrow the field to three.

These are:

John Giles Stainton 6th. Battalion The Dorset Regiment Killed October 1917

James Stainton 1st. Battalion The Border Regiment Killed 1st. July, 1916.

Jack Stainton 2nd. Battalion Lancashire Fusiliers Killed May 1917

Initially I thought that the second of these - James Stainton - was the one most likely to be "ours". The first - John Giles Stainton - was in a distant regiment. The third - Jack Stainton - was in a regiment closer to home, but no-one else from St. Bees had joined it.

James Stainton, however, was in our own County Regiment, as were fourteen others from St. Bees, and his position on the memorials is correct for a 1916 death. (The names appear in approximately date-of-death order). Against this, however, there were problems. The 1920 addresses for both his widow and his parents were in Kendal. James Stainton had enlisted there. And there is a J. Stainton on the Kendal memorial.

Almost by chance, at the Border Regiment's Museum in Carlisle, I found another Stainton reference. They had a record of 2363 Private Jack Stainton, serving in the "Whitehaven Pals" battalion of the regiment, having transferred there from the Lancashire Fusiliers. And he had enlisted originally at Whitehaven.

It would be better if we had a home address for Jack Stainton, to link him positively to St. Bees. But with the knowledge that 2963 Private J. Stainton of the Border Regiment and 38380 Private Jack Stainton of the Lancashires were actually one and the same, the identity of our J. Stainton appears more certain.